The Truth About Money: Why It's All an Illusion (And Why That Actually Matters)

If you prefer video, feel free to check out this YouTube video. It covers everything in this article from what money really is to why it's all an illusion, how banks create money from nothing, and why Bitcoin represents a new form of belief-based currency. Perfect for visual learners who want to see these concepts explained with charts and examples.

Key Takeaways

  • Money is not physically real - it's a shared belief or story that only has value because we collectively agree it does.

  • For something to function as money, it needs three qualities: medium of exchange, store of value (ideally), and unit of account.

  • 97% of money today is digital, and banks create new money when lending - they don't just lend existing deposits.

  • The US dollar has lost approximately 99% of its value over the last century, making fiat currencies poor stores of value.

  • Bitcoin represents a new form of money based on belief in math and code rather than institutions, with a fixed supply cap of 21 million coins.

Money is not real. There, I said it. But before you think I'm crazy and click away, give me just a few minutes to prove why this is an illusion and why it controls your life.

This revelation might sound shocking, but understanding the true nature of money can fundamentally change how you think about wealth, investing, and your financial future. In this comprehensive guide, we'll explore what money really is, why it's essentially a shared fiction, and how this knowledge can help you make better financial decisions.

What is Money, Really?

What is Money? (really)

When we look deeply into what money is, we realize that money is not real itself. Money is not something that actually exists in the physical world because the only thing that money is actually a shared belief or a story that we all agree on.

You might say, "Yes, that's true with our current digital money because it only exists in the cloud on the internet. But what about things like gold? That is definitely a thing that exists in the real world. Gold is just not a story."

Well, you are correct that gold exists. But the only reason that gold acted as money in the past is because we all agreed on gold being money. If, for example, during the Roman Empire where they used gold, someone cast a spell that made everyone forget that gold is money - let's say when everyone was asleep, they woke up and forgot it - then gold would simply not be money anymore.

The Power of Collective Belief

Gold only exists as money through a shared story, something that is shared between humans in our minds. And that is a fascinating thing about money - the more you think about it, the more fascinating it becomes.

Historian Yuval Noah Harari calls money a shared fiction that only works because we trust in it. I think that's a very solid explanation. Harari has written many books, including the super famous "Sapiens" and more recently "Nexus," which explores how humans have used information in the past and how AI will completely change the game in the future.

Without the collective belief, money loses all value. It's just paper, numbers, or code.

The 3 Things That Make Something "Money"

The 3 Essential Functions of Money

$ US Dollar
πŸ₯‡ Gold
β‚Ώ Bitcoin

1. Medium of Exchange

Trade without bartering

βœ“βœ“βœ“
βœ“βœ“
βœ“βœ“

2. Store of Value

Maintains worth over time

βœ—
βœ“βœ“βœ“
βœ“βœ“βœ“

3. Unit of Account

Standard for pricing

βœ“βœ“βœ“
βœ“
βœ—

Did you know? The US Dollar has lost ~99% of its value in the last century!

Track Money Supply Changes in Real-Time

Monitor how central banks create money and its impact on your investments

Start Free Trial Get TradingView Premium + $15 bonus

Now let's examine the three core functions of money. What do we need in order for something to be good money?

1. Medium of Exchange

This is something used to buy and sell without bartering. Bartering is basically when you trade one item for another, and this is super ineffective because for a trade to happen, you have to want exactly what I have, and I have to want exactly what you have. That is super unlikely.

That is where money comes in and what makes money so useful. Money is something that, as I said, is a shared belief. We all believe that if we get money, we can use it to buy something else, and that is what makes it work.

2. Store of Value (Ideally)

Money should be able to keep its value over time. The reason I wrote "ideally" here is because pretty much all types of money we have today - fiat currencies like the US dollar, the euro, and so on - are losing value very fast. They lose value every single day and are not good stores of value.

I think the US dollar has lost like 99% of its value in the last century. So it definitely cannot hold value well. A much better store of value is gold. And a new type of money we'll talk about soon is Bitcoin, which has not only stored value but has been increasing in value a lot recently.

3. Unit of Account

Money should ideally be used as a standard for pricing goods and services. Both the euro and US dollar are currently units of account, but Bitcoin is not that - at least not yet.

From Seashells to Digital Numbers: Money's Strange Evolution

Let's take a brief look at the history of money to understand how we got here.

The Barter System

Trade started as barter - trading an item for an item with no money involved.

Commodity Money

Then it evolved into commodity money, when we used things like:

  • Gold and silver

  • Seashells

  • Beads

  • Different kinds of stones

We have used many different types as money. What holds money together is the shared story that we all agree on - that this is money. For example, in prisons, they sometimes use cigarettes as money. Money can have a physical form, but what makes it money is not the physical form.

Fiat Money Era

In more recent days, it has shifted to fiat money. These are currencies like the US dollar which have no backing. The reason we use it is because we trust our government and we trust our central banks.

How Banks Create Money From Nothing

How Banks Create Money From Nothing

97%
Digital Money
πŸ’»
3%
Physical Cash
πŸ’΅

The Money Creation Process

1
You deposit $1,000

Bank receives your money

↓
2
Bank keeps fraction

May keep only $100 (10%)

↓
3
Lends out $900+

Creates NEW digital money!

↓
πŸ¦πŸ’°

Result: $1,000 deposit becomes $1,900+ in total money supply

❌ MYTH:

Banks lend out existing deposits

βœ… REALITY:

Banks create NEW money when lending

Monitor Real Money Supply Data

Track M1, M2 money supply and central bank policies affecting your wealth

Get TradingView Access economic data + $15 bonus

This is a very important question to ask yourself: How is money created today?

Most modern money is not printed, even though "money printing" is a word I use a lot because it's a simple mental image. Most money is actually created digitally. It's basically just printed by typing in a number on your computer, and just like that, we have created new money.

Fractional Reserve Banking

Through what's known as fractional reserve banking:

  • Banks only keep a fraction of deposits and lend out the rest

  • Many banks have no limit on the amount of money they can lend out

  • When they lend out, what many people think is that they lend out money that is already in the bank

But that's not really true because banks, when they are lending, are often actually creating completely new money. That is another crazy thing that most people don't know.

Here's an interesting fact: 97% of money today is digital - purely existing as numbers on screens and not physical cash. And this number is only increasing.

The Fiat Money Illusion: Why Trust is Breaking Down

Let's dive deeper into the illusion of fiat money and what this means.

Fiat money is just the belief in paper and trusting the banks that they are not eroding our trust too much. At the same time, fiat currencies can be created endlessly. There is no stop to how much money central banks and even normal banks can create through things like quantitative easing.

The 2020 Money Printing Spree

Just as an example, the US created $3.3 trillion in new money in 2020 alone. To put this in perspective, I think Apple has a market cap of like $3.3 trillion or even less. So the US created basically an Apple in money supply in just one year. That's insane in my opinion.

The Consequences

Excessive money printing can erode trust, and we are already seeing this:

  • Remember the inflation in 2020-2021

  • Money becomes worth less and less

  • This loss in trust is the reason behind the rise of Bitcoin

  • Gold is trading at an all-time high

  • People are losing trust in fiat currencies

Bitcoin: A New Form of Money?

Bitcoin represents a fascinating new chapter in the evolution of money.

Bitcoin: A New Form of Money?

πŸ’΅

Fiat Money

  • βœ— Unlimited printing
  • βœ— Controlled by few elites
  • βœ— Loses value over time
  • βœ— Opaque monetary policy
VS
β‚Ώ

Bitcoin

  • βœ“ Capped at 21 million
  • βœ“ Decentralized network
  • βœ“ Inflation-resistant
  • βœ“ Transparent & predictable
🀝

The Universal Truth: All Money Requires Belief

$

Trust in governments & banks

β‚Ώ

Trust in math & code

πŸ₯‡

Trust in physical properties

⚑

"Digital Gold" - Fixed supply meets modern technology

Start Trading Bitcoin Today

Join millions trading the future of money

Trade on Bybit Get up to $30,000 in bonuses

What Makes Bitcoin Different?

Bitcoin is:

  • Decentralized and digital

  • Capped at 21 million (there will never be more than 21 million bitcoins)

  • Created in response to fiat money concerns

  • Transparent, predictable, and designed to be inflation-resistant

When it comes to Bitcoin, no one can choose to print more money. The rules are set in stone. They are fixed. They are equal for everyone in the network. While with fiat money, the money supply is controlled by a few elites. That is one thing that makes Bitcoin so attractive to many people.

Many people, including me, see it as digital gold.

But It's Still Based on Belief

This is very important: This does not mean that Bitcoin is not based on belief. Bitcoin is the exact same thing as gold, the exact same thing as the US dollar. We need belief in order for Bitcoin to exist and work. If everyone tomorrow stops believing in Bitcoin, Bitcoin will be worth nothing.

If that sounds scary, it's not really scary because the same thing is true with the US dollar. The same thing is true with gold. It's always about collective belief. But when it comes to Bitcoin, it's belief in math and code, not institutions like central banks.

When Belief Fades, Currencies Die: Germany's Warning

Why does all this matter?

Money's value is social, not physical. This is important to realize. Physical parts of money can help reinforce the social contract or the illusion we have. For example, there's a very good reason why gold won as money in the past - the best countries and societies ended up choosing gold because of the physical aspects of gold. But still, it's not money unless we collectively believe in it.

Historical Lessons

It's real because we act as if it's real. From stone money on islands to Bitcoin, trust is the only constant.

When belief fades - for example, during times of hyperinflation like Germany after World War I in the Weimar Republic - their currency completely went to zero. The country lost all trust in their government. They printed endless amounts of money, and people stopped believing in the illusion. It lost all value. The illusion broke down.

The Power of Understanding

Understanding that money is a shared illusion helps us:

  • Question our financial systems

  • Protect our wealth

  • Maybe reinvent money (hint: Bitcoin is the most serious example to reinvent money we have today)

What This Means for Your Financial Future

Now that you understand money is an illusion based on collective belief, how can you use this knowledge?

  1. Diversify Beyond Fiat: Consider assets that don't rely solely on government trust

  2. Understand Inflation: Recognize that money printing directly erodes your purchasing power

  3. Explore Alternatives: Research Bitcoin, gold, and other stores of value

  4. Stay Informed: Monitor money supply changes and central bank policies

  5. Think Long-term: Plan for a world where traditional money may continue losing value

Money FAQ: Frequently Asked Questions about Money and How it Works

FAQ

If money isn't real, why does it have so much power over our lives?

Money has power precisely because we all believe in it. It's a shared fiction that works because everyone participates in the belief system. This collective agreement allows money to facilitate trade, store value, and organize economic activity. The illusion is powerful because it's universal - as long as everyone plays along, it functions as if it were real.

How do banks actually create money out of nothing?

Through fractional reserve banking, when banks make loans, they don't lend out existing deposits. Instead, they create new money digitally by simply crediting the borrower's account. For example, if you get a $100,000 mortgage, the bank doesn't transfer $100,000 from other accounts - it creates new digital money. This is why 97% of money today exists only as numbers on screens.

What's the difference between commodity money like gold and fiat money?

Commodity money like gold has intrinsic physical properties that make it valuable (scarcity, durability, divisibility), while fiat money has no intrinsic value and exists purely on government decree and trust. However, both require collective belief to function as money. Gold without the belief that it's money is just a shiny metal; paper currency without belief is just paper.

Can Bitcoin really replace traditional money if it's also based on belief?

Bitcoin could potentially serve as an alternative form of money, but like all money, it requires belief to function. The key difference is that Bitcoin's belief system is based on mathematical rules and code rather than trust in governments or banks. With its 21 million coin cap, it can't be infinitely printed like fiat currencies. However, it still needs widespread adoption and belief to succeed as money.

What happens when people lose faith in a currency?

When collective belief in a currency fails, hyperinflation can occur, as happened in Weimar Germany after WWI. The currency becomes worthless because people no longer trust it will hold value. This demonstrates that money's value is entirely dependent on social trust. People then typically flee to other stores of value like foreign currencies, gold, or barter systems.

How can I protect my wealth if money is just an illusion?

Understanding money's nature as a shared belief can help you diversify into assets that don't rely solely on one form of trust. This might include holding multiple currencies, precious metals, real estate, stocks, or cryptocurrencies. The key is not putting all your faith in one monetary system. Remember, this is educational information - always consult with financial professionals for personal advice.

Quiz: Test Your Understanding of Money

Test Your Understanding: The Money Illusion Quiz

1. What fundamentally makes something "money" according to the article?

2. What percentage of money today exists only as digital numbers?

3. Which of the three functions of money do fiat currencies struggle with most?

4. How much money did the US create in 2020 alone?

5. What is the maximum number of Bitcoin that will ever exist?

Conclusion

Money is not real - it's a shared story we all agree to believe. From seashells to gold to paper to digital numbers, money has always been about collective trust. Today, as that trust in fiat currencies erodes through endless money printing, we're seeing the rise of alternatives like Bitcoin that aim to create a more transparent, predictable monetary system.

Understanding that money is an illusion isn't meant to scare you - it's meant to empower you. Once you see through the illusion, you can make better decisions about how to protect and grow your wealth. Whether it's through traditional investments, gold, Bitcoin, or other assets, the key is recognizing that the value of money itself is not guaranteed.

The next step in your financial education journey is understanding money supply. What is money supply? How do we track it? And how can we use it to make better investment decisions? These are the questions that can help you navigate the changing landscape of money and finance.

Disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Investing involves substantial risk of loss. Always conduct your own research and consider your financial situation before making any investment decisions.

Read More on Mind Math Money

Mind Math Money

Trading & Investing Enthusiast

200K+ YouTube Community
16 Age Started Trading
500+ Educational Videos

Teaching traders to understand market psychology, technical analysis, and investing through clear beginner-friendly insights.

My Trading Journey

πŸ“ˆ

Started investing at 16 and became fascinated by how market psychology influences price movements. Still learning something new every day.

πŸŽ“

Love sharing what I've learned along the way. There's nothing quite like helping someone understand a concept that once confused me too.

🌟

Proud to have built a community where traders actively share insights and grow together through daily market analysis and discussion.

Want to join our learning journey?

Next
Next

Hedge Trading Strategy: The Ultimate Guide to Protecting Your Trades Without Stop-Losses