Break of Structure (BoS) and Change of Character (CHoCH) Trading Strategy
Master the market structure concepts that help identify perfect exit points and trend reversals.
When to Take Profits in Crypto, Stocks & Forex: The Complete Exit Trading Strategy Guide
Table of Contents
- Profit Taking Basics: Should You Sell Part or All of Your Position?
- Why Green Numbers Aren't Real Money (Until You Do This)
- Risk-to-Reward Ratio: The Foundation of Profit Taking
- The "Stress-Free" Profit Strategy Professional Traders Use
- Trailing Stop Loss: Let Winners Run While Protecting Profits
- Position Sizing & Risk Management: The Rule That Prevents Account Blowups
- Volatility-Based Targets: Using ATR & Bollinger Bands for Smarter Exits
- Time-Based Exits: Don't Get Stuck in Dead Trades
- Using Market Structure Trading to Time Perfect Exits
- FAQ
- Quiz
- Conclusion: Building Your Personal Profit-Taking System
Key Takeaways
-
Profit taking can involve selling your entire position or scaling out partially - partial exits often provide the best balance between securing gains and maintaining upside potential.
-
Green numbers in your trading app aren't real money until you lock in profits - having a systematic exit strategy prevents emotions from turning winners into losers.
-
Risk-to-reward ratios form the foundation of profit taking - aim for at least 1:2 to ensure profitability even with a moderate win rate.
-
Trailing stop losses and volatility-based targets help you capture more profits during strong trends while protecting against reversals.
-
Never risk more than 1-2% of your trading capital per trade - proper position sizing is crucial for long-term survival and consistent profitability.
What's worse – selling too early and missing a 10x gain, or holding for too long and watching your profits turn into losses? If you've ever struggled with this dilemma, you're not alone. In fact, knowing when to take profits is one of the most challenging aspects of trading, whether you're dealing with crypto, stocks, or forex markets.
After years of trading and teaching thousands of students, I've learned that profit-taking isn't just about maximizing gains – it's about developing a systematic approach that removes emotion from the equation. In this comprehensive guide, I'll share the exact strategies professional traders use to lock in profits while still capturing significant market moves.
Profit Taking Basics: Should You Sell Part or All of Your Position?
Profit Taking in Trading Explained
When most people think about profit-taking, they assume it means selling everything at once. However, effective profit-taking strategies are far more nuanced than that. You have two primary options:
1. Full Position Exit (100%) - Selling your entire position when your target is reached
2. Partial Exits (Scaling Out) - Selling portions of your position at different price levels
I've found that partial exits often provide the best balance between securing profits and maintaining upside potential. For instance, you might sell 50% of your position at your first target, then let the remaining 50% run with a trailing stop loss.
The key reasons we implement profit-taking strategies include:
Converting paper gains into actual money
Preventing winning trades from turning into losses
Managing risk during market structure shifts
Maintaining consistent profitability over time
Common profit-taking scenarios occur after large price moves, near significant resistance levels, or when you observe market structure changes that signal potential reversals. If you've been following market structure analysis (which I strongly recommend), these shifts can provide clear signals for when to start taking profits off the table.
Why Green Numbers Aren't Real Money (Until You Do This)
Here's a crucial truth that many traders learn the hard way: those green numbers on your trading app aren't actual money until you lock in your profits. I've seen countless traders watch substantial gains evaporate because they didn't have a clear exit strategy.
The psychological challenge is real. When you see your position up 50%, 100%, or even more, it's tempting to hold on for even bigger gains. But markets can reverse quickly, and without a systematic approach to profit-taking, you're essentially gambling with your returns.
A good profit-taking strategy helps you avoid two common emotional mistakes:
1. Selling Too Early - Exiting positions at the first sign of profit, missing out on significant moves
2. Holding Too Long - Refusing to take profits, eventually watching gains turn into losses
By implementing the strategies I'll share in this guide, you'll develop the discipline to make objective decisions based on predetermined criteria rather than emotions. This approach is fundamental to professional trading and consistent profitability.
Risk-to-Reward Ratio: The Foundation of Profit Taking
Risk-Reward Ratios at a Glance
1:2 Ratio
Risk $100
→
Make $200
✓ Profitable at 40% win rate
1:3 Ratio
Risk $100
→
Make $300
✓ Profitable at 30% win rate
1:4+ Ratio
Risk $100
→
Make $400+
✓ Trend-following trades
Quick Formula: If stop = 2% below entry & target = 6% above → 1:3 ratio
Visualize risk-reward ratios instantly with TradingView's position tools
Start Free TrialBefore diving into specific exit strategies, you need to understand the risk-to-reward ratio – it's the foundation of every successful trading plan. This ratio compares your potential gain to your potential loss on any given trade.
Common risk-to-reward ratios include:
1:2 (risking $100 to make $200)
1:3 (risking $100 to make $300)
1:4 or higher for trend-following strategies
When using trading platforms like TradingView, you can easily visualize these ratios using the long/short position tool. Here's how it works:
The entry point is your middle line
The stop-loss level (red area) represents your maximum risk
The target level (green area) represents your profit objective
The ratio automatically calculates based on these distances
For example, if your stop-loss is 2% below your entry and your target is 6% above, you have a 1:3 risk-to-reward ratio. This means you're risking $1 to potentially make $3.
I typically recommend beginners start with a minimum 1:2 ratio. This ensures that even with a 40% win rate, you can still be profitable over time. As you gain experience, you can adjust these ratios based on your strategy and market conditions.
The "Stress-Free" Profit Strategy Professional Traders Use
One of the most powerful yet underestimated strategies is partial exits, also known as scaling out. This approach has transformed my trading by reducing stress while maximizing profit potential.
Here's my favorite scaling-out strategy:
1. Scale to Break-Even When your trade reaches a 1:1 risk-to-reward ratio, sell enough of your position to cover your initial risk. For example, if you bought $1,000 worth of Bitcoin and it's now up enough to give you a $100 profit (matching your $100 risk), you might sell $200 worth. Now, even if the remaining position hits your stop-loss, you break even on the trade.
2. Lock in Core Profits At your main target (often 1:2 or 1:3), take another portion of profits. This ensures you walk away with gains regardless of what happens next.
3. Let Winners Run Keep a small portion (typically 25-30%) of your original position running with a trailing stop. This allows you to capture extended moves during strong trends.
This approach offers several psychological benefits:
Reduces stress since you've already locked in profits
Eliminates the regret of selling everything too early
Provides flexibility to adapt to changing market conditions
Balances risk management with profit maximization
I've found this strategy particularly effective in volatile markets like cryptocurrency, where massive moves can happen quickly but reversals can be equally swift.
Trailing Stop Loss: Let Winners Run While Protecting Profits
Trailing Stop Methods Comparison
1
Percentage-Based
Fixed % below highest price
Example: 10% trailing stop
✓ Best for crypto & volatile assets
2
ATR-Based
2-3x ATR below current price
Auto-adjusts to volatility
✓ Works in all market conditions
3
Moving Average
Exit when price closes below MA
Common: 20-day EMA
✓ Ideal for trend following
4
Market Structure
Trail below support levels
Uses previous swing lows
✓ Perfect for price action traders
⭐ Author's preferred method
⏰ Timeframe Tip: Day traders use tighter stops • Position traders use wider stops
Master trailing stops with professional trading tools
Get $30,000 Bonus Trade crypto with Bybit's advanced featuresUnlike fixed stop-losses that remain at one price level, trailing stops move with the market to protect your gains. This dynamic approach allows you to capture more profit during strong trends while still maintaining downside protection.
Types of trailing stops I use:
1. Percentage-Based Trailing Stops Set your stop a fixed percentage below the highest price reached. For example, a 10% trailing stop on a crypto position would sell if the price drops 10% from its peak.
2. ATR-Based Trailing Stops The Average True Range (ATR) indicator provides a volatility-adjusted trailing stop. I typically use 2-3x the ATR value below the current price. This adapts to market conditions – wider stops in volatile markets, tighter stops in calm markets.
3. Moving Average Trailing Stops Using a moving average (like the 20-day EMA) as your trailing stop can keep you in trends longer. Exit when price closes below the moving average.
4. Market Structure-Based Stops My preferred method involves trailing stops below key support levels or previous swing lows. This approach respects the market's natural rhythm.
The key is choosing a trailing stop method that aligns with your trading timeframe and risk tolerance. Day traders might use tighter stops, while position traders can afford to give trades more room to breathe.
Position Sizing & Risk Management: The Rule That Prevents Account Blowups
Here's a sobering statistic: most traders who blow up their accounts do so not because of a string of small losses, but because of one or two devastating trades where they risked too much. This is why position sizing is crucial to your profit-taking strategy.
The 1-2% Rule Never risk more than 1-2% of your total trading capital on a single trade. This means if you have a $10,000 account, your maximum risk per trade should be $100-200. This might seem conservative, but it's what keeps you in the game long-term.
How position sizing affects profit-taking:
Smaller positions = clearer thinking - When you're not risking too much, you can make objective decisions about when to take profits
Multiple positions possible - Proper sizing allows you to have several trades open, diversifying your risk
Scaling flexibility - You can add to winning positions (pyramiding) or scale out gradually without jeopardizing your account
Emotional stability - Knowing you can't lose more than 2% on any trade reduces the pressure to exit too early or hold too long
Remember, professional trading is about consistency, not home runs. By managing position sizes properly, you create a framework where your profit-taking decisions are based on strategy rather than fear or greed.
Volatility-Based Targets: Using ATR & Bollinger Bands for Smarter Exits
Volatility-Based Profit Targets
📊 ATR Target Levels
Conservative
1-2x ATR
Moderate
2-3x ATR
Aggressive
3-5x ATR
Quick Math: BTC at $30,000 + 3 ATR ($1,000 each) = $33,000 target
📈 Bollinger Bands Exits
1
Upper Band Touch
Take partial profits
2
Squeeze Breakout
Target 2-3x band width
3
Mean Reversion
Target middle band (20MA)
✓ Realistic targets
✓ Auto-adapts to market
✓ Statistical edge
Visualize ATR & Bollinger Bands instantly on any chart
Try TradingView Free 30-day premium trial + $15 bonusOne of the biggest mistakes traders make is setting arbitrary profit targets that don't align with how much a market typically moves. Volatility-based targets solve this problem by adapting to current market conditions.
Average True Range (ATR) Targets The ATR indicator measures average price movement over a specific period. I use it to set realistic profit targets:
Conservative target: 1-2x ATR from entry
Moderate target: 2-3x ATR from entry
Aggressive target: 3-5x ATR from entry
For example, if Bitcoin's daily ATR is $1,000 and you enter a long position at $30,000, a moderate target would be $32,000-33,000 (2-3 ATR moves).
Bollinger Bands Exit Strategy Bollinger Bands expand and contract based on volatility, providing dynamic profit targets:
Upper band touch - Consider taking partial profits when price reaches the upper band
Band squeeze breakouts - After a volatility contraction, set targets at 2-3x the band width
Mean reversion trades - Target the middle band (20-period MA) for counter-trend trades
These volatility-based approaches ensure your targets are:
Realistic given current market conditions
Adaptive to changing volatility
Based on statistical probabilities rather than hope
By aligning your profit targets with actual market behavior, you'll find yourself hitting targets more consistently while avoiding the frustration of unrealistic expectations.
Time-Based Exits: Don't Get Stuck in Dead Trades
Not all exits need to be price-based. Time-based exits are an often-overlooked strategy that can significantly improve your trading efficiency and overall returns.
When to use time-based exits:
Intraday trades - If a day trade hasn't moved in your favor within 2-3 hours, consider exiting to free up capital
Swing trades - Set a maximum hold time (e.g., 10 days) for trades that aren't performing as expected
Event-driven trades - Exit if the anticipated catalyst doesn't produce movement within your expected timeframe
Range-bound markets - If price hasn't broken out of a range within your anticipated timeframe, take your capital elsewhere
Benefits of time-based exits:
Prevents capital from being tied up in non-performing trades
Forces discipline and adherence to your original trade thesis
Reduces opportunity cost by freeing funds for better setups
Helps maintain trading momentum and psychological edge
I learned this lesson the hard way after holding onto stagnant positions for weeks, missing multiple profitable opportunities in other markets. Now, if a trade doesn't develop as expected within my predetermined timeframe, I move on without hesitation.
Using Market Structure Trading to Time Perfect Exits
Market structure analysis has become my primary tool for timing exits, especially in trending markets. By understanding the rhythm of higher highs, higher lows (uptrends) or lower highs, lower lows (downtrends), you can stay in winning trades longer while exiting before major reversals.
Key market structure exit signals:
Break of trend structure - Exit longs when price fails to make a new higher low in an uptrend
Change of character (ChoCH) - Watch for shifts in momentum or unusual price behavior
Key level breaks - Exit when price breaks below significant support (for longs) or above resistance (for shorts)
Multiple timeframe confluence - When structure breaks on both your trading and higher timeframes
Real-world example: Looking at Dogecoin's massive rally, traders using market structure could have stayed in the trade through multiple smaller pullbacks. The exit signal came when price clearly broke below the previous significant low, indicating the uptrend structure was broken.
This approach helps you:
Capture more of major moves
Avoid premature exits during normal retracements
Exit with confidence based on objective criteria
Reduce emotional decision-making
The key is defining your market structure rules clearly before entering any trade. This removes subjectivity and emotion from your exit decisions.
Profit Taking Strategy FAQ
Frequently Asked Questions
What's the biggest mistake traders make when taking profits?
The biggest mistake is not having a plan before entering the trade. Many traders enter positions with clear entry criteria but no exit strategy. This leads to emotional decision-making, often resulting in selling too early during minor pullbacks or holding too long and watching profits evaporate. Always define your profit targets and exit criteria before placing any trade.
Should I use the same profit-taking strategy for crypto, stocks, and forex?
While the core principles remain the same, you should adjust your strategy based on market characteristics. Crypto markets are typically more volatile, so wider stop-losses and bigger profit targets make sense. Forex pairs usually move in smaller percentages, requiring tighter stops and more modest targets. Stocks fall somewhere in between. The key is to use volatility-based indicators like ATR to adapt your targets to each market.
How do I avoid selling too early and missing big moves?
The best approach is to use partial exits or scaling out. Sell a portion of your position at predetermined targets to lock in profits, then let the remainder run with a trailing stop. This way, you secure gains while maintaining exposure to potentially larger moves. Also, using market structure analysis helps you stay in trends longer by only exiting when the trend structure actually breaks.
What's the best trailing stop method for beginners?
For beginners, I recommend starting with a simple percentage-based trailing stop (like 10-15% for stocks or 15-25% for crypto). It's easy to understand and implement. As you gain experience, you can move to more sophisticated methods like ATR-based stops or market structure stops. The key is choosing a method you can execute consistently without second-guessing.
How often should I review and adjust my profit-taking strategy?
Review your strategy monthly by analyzing your trade journal. Look for patterns: Are you consistently exiting too early? Are winning trades turning into losses? Adjust your approach based on actual results, not emotions. However, avoid changing strategies too frequently – give each approach at least 20-30 trades before making major adjustments.
Can I use multiple exit strategies on the same trade?
Absolutely! In fact, combining strategies often works best. For example, you might use a fixed target for your first partial exit, then switch to a trailing stop for the remainder. Or combine time-based exits with price targets – if your target isn't hit within your expected timeframe, exit anyway. The key is keeping your combined approach simple enough to execute without hesitation.
Test Your Profit Taking Knowledge (QUIZ)
Test Your Profit-Taking Knowledge
Conclusion: Building Your Personal Profit-Taking System
Mastering when to take profits is arguably more important than knowing when to enter trades. Throughout this guide, we've covered multiple strategies – from basic risk-to-reward ratios to advanced market structure analysis. The key is not to use all of these techniques at once, but to build a personalized system that fits your trading style and psychological makeup.
Start with these action steps:
Define your baseline strategy - Choose between full exits or scaling out
Set minimum risk-to-reward ratios - Never enter a trade without clear targets
Implement at least one trailing stop method - Protect profits while allowing for upside
Practice with small positions - Build confidence before scaling up
Track your results - Document which exit strategies work best for your style
Remember, the goal isn't to catch every penny of every move – it's to consistently lock in profits while managing risk. Even professional traders rarely catch entire moves perfectly. What matters is having a systematic approach that you can execute consistently, regardless of market conditions or emotions.
The difference between amateur and professional traders often comes down to exit strategy. By implementing the techniques in this guide, you're taking a crucial step toward trading like a professional. Stay disciplined, keep learning, and always remember: profits are only real when they're in your account.
Disclaimer: This content is for educational purposes only and should not be considered financial advice. Trading involves substantial risk and is not suitable for every investor. Always do your own research and consider consulting with a qualified financial advisor before making investment decisions.
Read More on Mind Math Money
Understanding Strong Highs, Weak Highs, Strong Lows, and Weak Lows
Learn to identify key price levels that signal when to hold positions or take profits.
Master Support and Resistance Trading: Complete Guide for All Markets 2025
Discover how to use support and resistance levels to set optimal profit targets and exit points.
ATR Indicator Trading Strategy: Master Volatility for Better Breakouts and Risk Management
Learn how to use the ATR indicator for volatility-based profit targets and trailing stops.
Want to join our learning journey?
